Abortion is a punishable offence under the Indian Penal Code, 1980. It punishes the person doing it, aiding it and even consenting to it. The punishment ranges up to life imprisonment. A reasonable doubt that arises here is: Are there no circumstances when abortion can be done legally? 

Let’s consider a hypothetical case. There is a girl named Usha. Usha is sixteen years old. She has been suffering from mental illness and stays in an orphanage. She has been raped and is now bearing a child of the sex crime. Usha cannot understand the repercussion of having a child. She is herself a dependant and under no circumstance can she handle the burden of a new life. What can she do? Under the Indian Penal Code, the doctor cannot help her abort the child.

The Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971 provides certain exceptions to the rule laid down under the Indian Penal Code. The term ‘medical termination’ is nothing but abortion. The Act provides for the exceptional circumstances when abortion is permitted and the act would no longer be punishable. By this we mean that neither the doctor nor the consenting person shall be liable to punishment.

The three grounds on which abortion can happen are as follows:

  1. On grounds of health- This includes conditions which involve danger to life, a risk of physical or mental health of the mother.
  2. On humanitarian grounds- Such grounds arise when the child borne is a result of any sexual abuse (maybe rape)
  3. On eugenic grounds- These involve risks related to the child. It may include risk of deformities and diseases.

It is believed that the Act was enacted to provide immunity to doctors specifically against being prosecuted for causing abortion. However, not all doctors are protected under the Act. The protection is afforded to “registered medical practitioners” who are a different class of doctors defined under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956.

There are two categories of cases that may arise:

  1. When pregnancy is not more than twelve weeks old.
  2. When pregnancy is more than twelve weeks old but not more than twenty weeks old.

Situation in both the cases are different to the extent that under the first category, one medical practitioner, and in the second category, two medical practitioners believe that there exists any of the above stated three grounds for effecting abortion.

The question now arises is whose consent will be required for terminating the pregnancy. The answer to this varies depending upon the age and mental health of the women. If the woman is under the age of eighteen years or of unsound mind, the consent of her guardian shall be taken before terminating the pregnancy. In other circumstances, the consent of the woman shall suffice.

Going back to the case of Usha, she can get abortion done. Her guardian can give the consent for abortion and a “registered medical practitioner” can come to her aid.


Written by,

Divya


Image from here