It’s not just the curious case of Kanhaiya Kumar of JNU but
SEDITION and infliction of such charges has a long history, let’s take a tour.
What is sedition?
The Constitution of India does not define the word
sedition. Section 124-A of the Indian Penal Code defines the offence of
‘Sedition’ and provides as follows:
“Whoever, by words, either spoken or
written, or by signs, or by visible representation, or otherwise, brings or
attempts to bring into hatred or contempt, or excites or attempts to excite
disaffection towards the Government established by law in India….”
It is further provided that the word ‘disaffection’ in
this section includes disloyalty and feelings of enmity.
Origin of Sedition Law
The origin of sedition law in India is linked to the
Wahabi Movement of 19th century. This movement, centred around Patna was an
Islamic revivalist movement, whose stress was to condemn any change into the
original Islam and return to its true spirit. The movement was led by Syed
Ahmed Barelvi. The movement was active since 1830s but in the wake of 1857
revolt, it turned into armed resistance, a Jihad against the British.
Subsequently, the British termed Wahabis as traitors and rebels and carried out
extensive military operations against the Wahabis. The movement was fully
suppressed after 1870. British also introduced the term “sedition” in the
Indian Penal Code 1870 to outlaw speech that attempted to “excite disaffection
towards the government established by law in India”.
Sedition Law and Independence Movement
British used the sedition law to quell the Indian freedom
struggle and retain imperial power.
·
The first
known use of Sedition law was against Jogendra Chandra Bose, editor of
“Bangobasi”, who was charged in 1891 for his criticism of the “Age of
Consent Bill” whereby he said that the bill was disastrous to religion and was
being forcefully imposed on Indians. He later apologized for what he had
written.
·
During
freedom struggle, targets of this law included renowned nationalists like
Mahatma Gandhi, Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Annie Besant.
·
Later Bal
Gangadhar Tilak was also was also tried under sedition law, who criticised the
killing by Chapekar brothers but also blamed the British government for
bringing the situation in the country to a brink, thus instigating the
revolutionaries. Tilak was convicted and sentenced to six years imprisonment to
Mandalay jail.
·
Later
Mahatma Gandhi was tried in 1922 for his articles published in the
magazine Youth India. Mahatma Gandhi said that the section 124-A
under which he was charged is perhaps the prince among the political sections
of the IPC designed to suppress the liberty of the citizen. He further said
that “Affection cannot be manufactured or regulated by the law. If one has no
affection for a person, one should be free to give the fullest expression to
his disaffection, so long as he does not contemplate, promote or incite to
violence.”
Relevant Laws as to Sedition in India
·
Indian
Penal Code (IPC), 1960
Section 124A
forms the main section that deals with sedition in the Indian Penal Code.
124A64 carries with it a maximum sentence of imprisonment for life.
·
Criminal
Procedure Code (Cr.P.C.), 1973
The
CrPC contains section 9565 which gives the government the right to forfeit
material punishable under section 124A on stating grounds. The section requires
two conditions to be fulfilled, (i) that the material is punishable under the
mentioned sections (ii) the government gives grounds for its opinion to forfeit
the material.
·
Unlawful
Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), 1967
Supporting
claims of secession, questioning territorial integrity and causing or intending
to cause disaffection against India fall within the ambit of ‘unlawful
activity’ (Section 2(o) UAPA).66 Section 1367 punishes unlawful activity with
imprisonment extending to seven years and a fine.
·
Prevention
Of Seditious Meetings Act, 1911
The
Seditious Meetings Act, which was enacted by the British a century ago to
control dissent by criminalizing seditious meetings, continues to be on our
statute books. Section 568 of the Act empowers a District Magistrate or
Commissioner of Police to prohibit a public meeting in a proclaimed area if, in
his/ her opinion, such meeting is likely to promote sedition or disaffection or
to cause a disturbance of the public tranquility. Considering this legislation
was specifically enacted to curb meetings being held by nationalists and those
opposed to the British, the continuation of this archaic legislation is
completely unnecessary and undemocratic.
Recent cases of use of sedition law
In free
India, sedition law has been used against many people such as:
·
In 2012,
cartoonist Aseem Trivedi was arrested with sedition charges because
his banners and cartoons mocked constitution, parliament and India’s
national flag.
·
In 2010,
Noor Mohammad Bhat, a lecturer from Gandhi Memorial College was arrested
for setting an anti-India question paper.
·
In 2010,
writer Arundhati Roy and SAR Gilani were arrested for making anti-Indian speech
in New Delhi In 2009, V Gopalaswamy (Vaiko) was slapped with sedition charges
for his statements against India’s sovereignty in speech on Sri Lanka’s war
with LTTE
·
In 2007,
Binayak Sen was arrested for sedition charges due to his help to carry messages
to Maoists in Chhattisgarh.
Article 124-A of IPC v/s Article 19(1) of Constitution
In
the Ram Nandan vs. State (1958), the Allahabad High Court held
section 124-A to be unconstitutional citing that the section restricts freedom
of speech (Article 19) in disregard of whether the interest of public
order or the security of the state is involved and is capable of striking at
the very root of the Constitution which is free speech.
But, however
the said judgement was overruled by Supreme Court in the Kedarnath Singh v
State of Bihar (1962). The Supreme Court said that:
“This section
should be construed as to limit their application to acts involving intention
or tendency to create disorder or disturbance of law and order, or incitement
to violence. If used arbitrarily, the sedition law would violate freedom of
speech and expression guaranteed by the Constitution under Article 19?.
Kanahiya,
Wrong intention or Wrong ways?
Sedition is no just another charge from the
books of law, it s basically what our old hindi movies termed as Desh Vidroh or
Desh se Gaddari, yes, a charge of the most fiery offence. But, the case of
Kanahiya seems out of the box, Basically, as all of such these cases are, an
unending and confusing war between Freedom of Speech guaranteed by the
Constitution of India under article 19(2) and the act of sedition made
punishable under the ambit of section 124(2) of the Indian Penal Code.
The robe of section 124-A of IPC, has been time
and again used by the government in force, used to curb the menace and
objections raised by the critics; but the very section has also alike, the
colonial times created a apprehension in minds of citizens to think before they
speak against the nation.
The basic contention here is whether the
anti-patriot (as termed by the media) slogans by Kanahiya were to be covered
under the free speech or were of such grave element that could have resulted in
Public Disorder.
His
intentions seemed true to raise voice for family members of Afzal Guru, for not
getting his body to cremate (Governmental Steps of UPA regime) but his methods
seemed wrong, anti-traditional, anti-acceptable or maybe anti-national.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of DailyO.in or the India Today Group. The writers are solely responsible for any claims arising out of the contents of this article.